News Details

img

Uni Franchise Controls

Tie franchise growth to student outcomes, regulator told

Introducing rules that make enrolment growth “conditional on student outcomes” could help to restore trust in franchised provision, according to a report that examines how one university has expanded its partnerships at a time when most others are cancelling theirs.

The Office for Students (OfS) should play a greater role in governing which institutions are allowed to expand their subcontracted activity and which are not, argues a policy note published by the Higher Education Policy Institute (Hepi) on 19 November.

The publication – which looks at how the University of Wolverhampton has expanded its UK franchising and transnational education activity over the past two years – suggests that subcontracting partnerships could benefit from “explicit recruitment controls” in situations where a lead institution retains accountability but teaching is delivered by a separate organisation.

Doing so would protect students by linking recruitment growth to “published continuation, completion, and progression outcomes”, which could be benchmarked against “comparable provision” at the institution leading a partnership, the report suggests.

The policy note, Partnership Accountability and Institutional Resilience, focuses specifically on how Wolverhampton has used franchising arrangements to extend higher education into areas with historically low levels of participation.

It responds to substantial growth in the industry, with Department for Education (DfE) figures revealing that franchised student numbers rose from 50,430 in 2018-19 to 135,850 in 2022-23 – an increase of about 169 per cent.

But the arrangements have often been a headache for the sector, thanks to concern about their quality control and student protections. Outcomes for franchised students often languish below OfS thresholds for continuation and progression, and only just meet completion baselines. Many universities that move heavily into franchising have now scaled back their partnerships.

The operations have also faced scrutiny because of widespread student loan fraud. In 2022-23, franchised provision accounted for 53 per cent of the £4.1 million in fraud detected by the Student Loans Company (SLC).

According to the Hepi findings, such risks are “real” but can be mitigated by appropriate governance.

In the case of Wolverhampton, the report states, “controlled” growth is essential, with new partners permitted to operate just one course, at one site and with one intake, with a maximum of 200 students.

Any expansion requires university agreement as well as a mandated continuation threshold of 85.3 per cent.

The report recommends five priorities for “strengthening partnership governance”. One consideration should be that the OfS, the DfE and the SLC explore “agreed recruitment allowances” in the form of a limit on publicly funded new entrants to franchised courses.

“New partners should operate within probationary caps,” the report suggests. “Serious or persistent underperformance should trigger consideration of reduced recruitment or suspension, with arrangements to protect existing students.”

The note also calls for the DfE and the OfS to commission an independent review of how an incoming new registration requirement will work.

From 2028-29, delivery partners with 300 or more franchised students must be registered with the OfS for new students to access public student finance. A review of this new mechanism should answer two questions, the report says: are the new rules protecting students and public money, and are they making it harder for some people to access higher education?

David Atkinson, director of educational partnerships at Wolverhampton, told Times Higher Education: “The key question for any partnership is whether students are succeeding. Evidence of success must come from sustained performance over time, including student continuation, completion and progression into employment or further study.

“That is why we support an approach where new partnerships demonstrate strong outcomes before being permitted to expand. Growth should be linked to evidence that students are receiving a high-quality educational experience and achieving positive outcomes.”

Partnerships can make a “significant contribution” to widening access, Atkinson said, but accountability and student success are paramount.

“Clear oversight, robust monitoring and proportionate controls are essential to maintaining confidence in partnership provision,” he said.

“Where performance falls below expectations and does not improve, universities should be prepared to intervene, restrict growth or pause recruitment, while ensuring that existing students are fully supported to complete their studies.”

georgia.luckhurst@timeshighereducation.com

  • SOCIAL SHARE :