The UK’s new residence rules make overseas students feel betrayed
When a friend of mine, an international PhD student, moved to the UK in 2019 for an academic internship, he was not motivated by the thought of staying in the country long term. That remained true even after he embarked on a PhD in 2021. But then his native Russia launched a full-scale invasion of Ukraine, and his fervently expressed opposition to the action meant that it would be dangerous for him to return home.
“I just faced the reality [that] I had to plan my life in the UK,” he told me. “It wasn’t always easy, and with time I think I became more realistic about the [political] situation in the country, but I still love living here. And I think I’ve done a lot to integrate into the local culture and society.”
He has also taught undergraduates within the limitations of his student visa, lecturing and supervising, creating course content, corresponding with students, marking, advising and examining, as well as organising university events.
Yet none of that will help him remain in the UK long term. The government’s revised proposals for new settlement rules, announced earlier this month, contain a significant change for international students and graduates. Under the new earned settlement framework, it was explicitly confirmed that time spent in the UK on student and graduate visas will no longer count towards obtaining indefinite leave to remain. Now, international students will need to move on to eligible immigration routes to start building qualifying time towards settlement.
This, of course, will only add to the huge expense of studying in the UK. On top of sky-high international tuition fees, most international students pay £558 to apply for a study visa, plus £776 a year for the Immigration Health Surcharge (and £500 or £1,000 more if they need quick processing).
Want to write for THE? Click for more information
They might, therefore, spend thousands of pounds on immigration costs alone, before factoring in accommodation and living expenses. My Russian friend has spent more than £5,700 on the student visa and extensions – often needed for completing a PhD, which has a long examination process. And after five years in the UK “contributing to the culture and economy, and becoming a member of the society”, he now feels “betrayed” by a system that has “for many years been built [on the] effort of people moving into the UK from different parts of the world and making this country what it is: a beautiful melting pot of cultures…It just feels like the system is doing everything possible to discourage those who are already in the country or who are planning to move into the country, from properly integrating.”
All the more so because time spent on a post-study graduate visa will also no longer count towards permanent residence, all the while piling on the expense: the application fee is £937, and the health surcharge is £3,105 for PhD students.
Another international doctoral graduate I know, who has taught countless undergraduates and who volunteers as a pet-sitter in the local community, does not see that as good value – and that is part of the reason she is making plans with her husband to move to another European country in the spring.
“I struggle to understand who would want to pay around £4,000 for the graduate visa,” she explained. “Since the student visa also doesn’t count towards indefinite leave to remain, I have no hopes of settling in England for the foreseeable future – the four years I spent here, studied, worked and paid taxes don’t amount to anything.”
She predicts that the rule change will decrease UK recruitment of international master’s and PhD students in particular, because they have “more concrete plans, and often a more pressing need [than undergraduates], to settle and make a living”.
Want to write for THE? Click for more information
That need to make a living might be particularly dissuasive given the state of the UK’s academic job market, particularly in the humanities.
“Paying [an] exorbitant sum of money to ensure that I can compete with other students [for jobs] is grim enough,” another final-year humanities PhD student told me. “This perspective gets grimmer with the prolongation of visa tracks.” He has also decided to leave.
Others are even more cynical. One PhD student said that while he “would have been open to staying” in the UK, he now feels the graduate visa “guarantees nothing”, making “the period between finishing your studies and starting a job in the UK…a period of immense stress and hardship”, with the risk that it ultimately proves “a significant waste of time, effort and money”.
Aside from the personal cost, there will also be an impact on universities – both financially and academically.
A former international PhD student who returned to his home country last year thinks the visa changes will “further undermine the ability of UK universities to attract and retain international talent”, given that “the exorbitant cost of a graduate visa was [already] difficult, if not impossible, to sustain on the precarious, part-time and poorly paid work that is typically available to PhD graduates”. He feels the end result will be “a less competitive university sector for the UK”.
And it is not just international students who feel this way. One British postdoc told me that the “fundamental unfairness” of the changes would “lead to a loss of trust in the UK as a destination for global talent”.
This is what the government fails to recognise. Education is a process of mutual transformation. International students are both receiving the UK’s world-class education and helping to make it. If the latest visa proposals are implemented, the students will transform and be transformed by other countries – while the UK sector is changed only for the worse.
Juliette Bretan is a researcher, writer and broadcaster on culture and geopolitics in the UK, Poland and east-central Europe. She is a postdoctoral affiliate in the Faculty of English at the University of Cambridge.