News Details

img

Sweden Academic Freedom

 

HE institutions adopt code for institutional autonomy

On 21 October, the General Assembly of the Association of Swedish Higher Education Institutions (SUHF) adopted a Code for Swedish Universities. It is a statement of principles agreed by the sector itself, drawing on the Magna Charta Universitatum, the Kalven Report, the Chicago Principles and Swedish law.

The Code covers academic freedom, collegiality, international collaboration and the role of universities in society, and asks university leaders at all levels to safeguard institutional autonomy and to uphold an objective stance on complex issues.

The Code is part of a wider Swedish discussion regarding constitutional protection, organisational form and institutional neutrality.

For several years the SUHF has called for academic freedom and institutional autonomy to be anchored in the Instrument of Government, in position statements (2021, 2024) and a joint statement (2023) with the Swedish Association of University Teachers and Researchers and the Swedish National Union of Students. The campaign is now also supported by the Young Academy of Sweden and the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences.

Institutional autonomy is not an end in itself

In January 2026 the Government appointed an inquiry into a more suitable organisational form for state universities, including an alternative to their status as government agencies, which is unusual internationally (due 31 March 2027).

For SUHF, institutional autonomy is not an end in itself. It protects the academic freedom of researchers and students. The Code describes universities as a critically reflective force in the development of society.

As explained to the General Assembly, and in line with the Kalven Report, they play this role through their activities (free inquiry, collegial review and education), rather than by taking institutional positions on contested political questions.

Autonomy and neutrality thus work together to protect academic freedom, while individual researchers and students remain free to take part in public debate.

“At the European level, we are following the Commission’s forthcoming proposal for a European Research Area Act, expected before the end of the year, which is widely seen as likely to address academic freedom,” Christopher Sönnerbrandt, deputy secretary general of SUHF said.

SUHF shares the view that legal protection is necessary but not sufficient, and that sector owned instruments have a role alongside it; the Swedish Code is one example of what such an instrument can look like nationally.

University World News asked several stakeholders if they are optimistic that the Code might be a first step towards better protection of academic freedom in Sweden.

Academic freedom under threat across Europe

Jens Stilhoff Sörensen is a lecturer in Peace and Development Studies and International Relations at Gothenburg University’s School of Global Studies and also a research fellow at the Swedish Institute of International Affairs (SIIA). He is also a representative for Academic Rights Watch, an organisation with the objective to promote and monitor academic freedom, and the author of ”Academic freedom and its enemies: Lessons from Sweden”.

“What is needed is academic freedom for the individual researchers, teachers and professors, not institutional autonomy. The latter can just create vice chancellor dictatorships. Academic freedom is under serious threat in the European Union, Norway and Britain now with direct censorship and sanctioning of dissidents,” Sörensen stated.

Kajsa Widgren, who is an analyst at the Swedish Secretariat for Gender Research at the University of Gothenburg and the author of Critical perspectives on academic freedom, told University World News that SUHF’s Code is very much in line with the Magna Charta code.

“The problem with these sorts of documents is often that they are written in an abstract way which is of little help in situations where somebody’s academic freedom is actually threatened, or if different subjects’ academic freedoms are in conflict with each other. The code does not offer any concrete formulation of the problems that the codex is supposed to address,” she said.

“Besides a problem formulation, I think what needs to be part of a document like this, if it aims to be a guideline of any sort, is a more elaborate notion of what could be called ‘academic and professional norms’ as something that is not possible for individual subjects within academia to simply raise above.”

By way of illustration, she referenced the arguments raised by theorist Judith Butler in “Academic Norms, Contemporary Challenges: A reply to Robert Post on academic freedom”, in the book Academic Freedom after 11 September (edited by Robert Pos).

Tim Ekberg, senior advisor to the office of the vice-chancellor at Lund University and a member of the SUHF expert group on analysis, who is the author of the SUHF publication “Academic freedom as in the Nordic countries – A study on how academic freedom has developed for universities in Denmark, Finland and Norway with proposals how this can increase in Sweden” and “Academic Freedom and Institutional Autonomy” (SUHF, 2023), told University World News: “The Code is intended to serve as a support and a point of reference for higher education institutions. It highlights the fundamental principles that underpin universities.

“These core values can, for instance, serve as a foundation for these institutions when they develop their strategies, determine their direction, and define their relationship with society.”

He noted that the Code provides a clear description of what distinguishes higher education institutions from other societal entities and emphasises that “robust academic freedom and well-defined institutional autonomy” are essential prerequisites for the fulfillment of their mission.

“Hopefully, the Code also can contribute to a shift in which the autonomy of higher education institutions is more explicitly recognised – both within the Swedish Constitution, the Higher Education Act and in the political governance of resources and decisions,” Ekberg said.

‘Precarious employment silences academia’

Sanna Wolk, president of the Swedish Association of University Teachers and Researchers (SULF) told University World News that SUHF’s principles are sound, but academic freedom requires direct government funding and secure employment.

“SULF welcomes the fact that SUHF’s new Code of Conduct places such clear emphasis on the academic freedom of individual teachers and researchers. However, when we look at this from the perspective of our members’ everyday realities within university departments, fine principles on paper are simply not enough,” she said.

Wolk stressed that for members to exercise academic freedom in practice, structural barriers must be dismantled.

She pointed out that the external funding system actively undermines independence by forcing researchers to waste time chasing grants and aligning with short-term trends.

To counter this threat to independent research, SULF demands secure, significantly increased direct government funding through institutional block grants.

“Precarious employment silences academia,” she said. “The widespread use of fxed-term contracts is one of the greatest threats to academic freedom.

“A member employed on short-term contracts or dependent on securing the next external research grant is, in practice, less able to challenge established views or pursue controversial research for fear of losing their job. Secure employment is the cornerstone of independent research.”

Wolk added that the Code should be implemented locally because it is voluntary and lacks sanctions for non-compliance by higher education institutions.

She noted that SULF aims to leverage this document to ensure accountability among university leaders, ultimately seeking robust constitutional protection for academic freedom.

She emphasised that while SUHF’s Code of Conduct is perceived as a positive start, true academic freedom requires guaranteed long-term government funding and secure employment within higher education.

Code is ‘not enough’

Agneta Bladh, former secretary of state for higher education and research and chair of the Swedish Research Council (2016 to 2022), who oversaw an investigation into Sweden’s increased internationalisation of universities and university colleges in 2018 and 2019, told University World News that a national code from all higher education institutions in the country gives more attention to the issue of academic and research freedom in the national political sphere.

“The Code gives much more guidance for faculty, students and leadership,” she said. “But this is not enough; it is important to have academic freedom in the constitution, which SUHF is striving for, not only in the legislation as today. I totally agree with the importance of including academic freedom more clearly in the constitution.”

She emphasised that SUHF has focused on academic freedom for many years, particularly regarding institutional autonomy, which will soon be reviewed in what she sees as a crucial inquiry into a more suitable organisational form for Swedish higher education institutions that will affect their international collaboration due to their current status as state-owned entities, which limits their ability to independently form legal agreements with foreign institutions regarding joint degrees and similar initiatives.

Professor Emeritus at the University of Oslo (UiO), Ole Petter Ottersen, former president of the University of Oslo (2009 to 2017) and former president of Karolinska Institutet (2017 to 2023), told University World News: “I welcome the initiative taken by SUHF and the adoption of the Code for Swedish Universities.

Academic freedom and institutional autonomy are fundamental prerequisites for universities to fulfil their role in society.

“Clearly, evidence-based policymaking and sound democratic governance depend on independent academic institutions that are able to question prevailing assumptions, challenge established interests and, when necessary, speak truth to power.”

He stressed that while constitutional protection is vital for academic freedom, legislation alone is insufficient. Using the United States as an example, he explained that academic freedom can be subtly undermined through actions such as restricting research funding, dismantling advisory bodies, altering peer review processes, and political interference, even without formal legal changes.

He suggested that the erosion of independent scholarship can occur gradually, emphasising that constitutional provisions are not enough to safeguard academic freedom, as even established democracies may exhibit such declines.

“This is why I believe that the Swedish initiative is important for reasons that extend beyond the pursuit of constitutional protection,” he stated.

“As I see it, the Code represents a commitment by the university sector itself to articulate, uphold and defend the principles that distinguish universities from other societal institutions. Such sector-owned commitments are valuable because they create a basis for holding university leadership accountable.

“For example: university leaders could embed academic freedom clauses in all funding and partnership agreements, strengthen institutional competence and governance to resist political or donor interference, create a culture for responsible internationalisation, diversify funding sources to reduce dependency on single actors, protect scientists that are attacked because of their research, and create rapid-response mechanisms for scholars at risk (for example, through the Scholars at Risk networks),” he explained.

Advocacy is needed

For Ottersen, university leaders, researchers, students and society should advocate for understanding the importance of academic freedom and institutional autonomy, which he sees as essential for a democratic, knowledge-based society.

He emphasised that protecting these rights necessitates effective legislation, robust institutions, and an engaged academic community committed to defending knowledge independence.

“The United States offers instructive examples of how academic freedom can be undermined through instruments other than direct legislative restrictions. The Trump administration has, for instance, invoked a rarely used provision of the 1952 Immigration and Nationality Act, originating in the Cold War era, in attempts to deport foreign students and scholars on grounds connected to their political expression,” he stated.

According to Ottersen, existing civil-rights legislation and federal funding have been used to pressure universities regarding governance and academic priorities, illustrating how legal instruments from different contexts can challenge academic independence. He stressed that while constitutional guarantees are crucial, they alone cannot ensure the respect for academic freedom in practice.

Professor Daniel Tarschys, emeritus professor at Stockholm University and lead author of a government investigation into the independence of universities published in 2008 that was widely discussed but ultimately shelved, commented to University World News: “The freedom of research is now inscribed into the Instrument of government (regeringsformen) 2:18. The formula ‘academic freedom’ is not employed and might be considered to be too imprecise.

“Many rights and principles in this chapter are subject to further rules set out in law. What this means is that legislation by parliament is required and that ordinary rules prescribed by the government (förordningar) are not sufficient. The guarantees in this chapter are then, in most cases, not absolute.

“Apart from the symbolic and proclamatory function of this chapter, its practical mission is to regulate the division of competence between the legislature and the government.”

  • SOCIAL SHARE :